Beethoven | Piano Trio No. 5 in D Maj Op. 70 No. 1 'The Ghost' |
Elfrida Andrée | Piano Trio No. 2 in G minor |
Schubert | Piano Trio No. 1 in B flat D 898 |
The Sitkovetsky Piano Trio made a welcome return to Lewes
for the second concert of the 2023-24 season. The programme was the usual
mixture of familiar and unfamiliar which always makes these concerts something
to anticipate but with the slight risk of a possible disappointment. But that
certainly wasn’t the case this time. The programme began with Beethoven’s
‘Ghost’ trio. The first movement is full of the vivid contrasts that were so
characteristic of Beethoven’s compositions during this period. The way in which
the trio played brought this out very clearly – they were particularly
impressive in the way in which each part shone through in both soft and loud
passages. Chris Darwin’s programme notes reminded us that the title of this
trio comes from a comment by Czerny, that the second movement reminded him of
the appearance of the ghost of Banquo in Shakespeare’s Macbeth. Waiting for the
performance to commence I found myself wondering whether I would also be reminded
of another Shakespearian ghost, Hamlet’s father. I still have a vivid image of
his appearance in Brett Dean’s opera at Glyndebourne in 2017 – where the ghost
was played by Sir John Tomlinson – the NYS president. For me at least the music
in that movement expresses an emotion closer to despair, rather than fear, and
it was brilliantly caught by this performance. Fortunately the mood changes
completely for the final movement, bringing the work to a much happier
conclusion.
The first half of the concert ended with a trio written by a
composer who was completely new to me – Elfrida Andrée. Before the performance
Alexander Sitkovetsky explained that the trio had only discovered the piece in
the summer of 2022 because they had been asked for a programme of pieces by
women composers who were contemporaries of Bruckner. They ended up choosing
this G minor trio and two others in the same key by Cécile Chaminade and Clara
Schumann and the programme was played at the Brucknerhaus in Linz earlier this
year. G minor is often used in dark and
dramatic music (Mozart’s 40th and Beethoven’s 5th
symphonies for example) and that was also true of this piece, especially in the
first movement which seemed to me to have a Brahmsian intensity to it. A real discovery, and fortunately my music
app (Idagio) lists some other Andrée works that I will explore over the next
few weeks.
The second half consisted of a single work – Schubert’s late
B flat piano trio, so there was less of the intensity that characterised the
first half. But it is wonderful work,
especially the second movement Andante. The Sitkovetsky really brought out the
interplay between the instruments as they they ‘threw’ the themes from one
player to another. And some beautiful rippling piano, really precise yet full
of feeling.
The overall impression from the concert was of an ensemble
whose playing is so well integrated. The piano never dominated the two string
instruments and they had a wonderful knack of allowing individual voices to be
heard with real clarity. It is little surprise that they have received a clutch
of awards in the last few years. Let’s hope that their second visit to Lewes
won’t be their last.
Reviewer: Pete Clifton
Photographer: David James